Severus Snape Casting Bombshell: Paapa Essiedu or Benedict Cumberbatch for HBO’s Harry Potter Series?

The wizarding world is buzzing with excitement—and a dash of controversy—as HBO’s highly anticipated Harry Potter TV series inches closer to reality. The latest casting news has set tongues wagging, with British actor Paapa Essiedu reportedly stepping into the greasy-haired, potion-brewing shoes of Severus Snape, while fans toss around Benedict Cumberbatch as a dream alternative.

Once brought to life by the legendary Alan Rickman, this complex character is now at the heart of a heated debate among fans. So, from Paapa Essiedu to Benedict Cumberbatch, who does the Internet think should nab the role of Severus Snape in HBO's Harry Potter Series? Here’s everything we know about this magical casting shake-up as of March 11, 2025.

Who Is Paapa Essiedu, the Rumored Severus Snape?

Paapa Essiedu, a 34-year-old British actor, is reportedly closing his deal to portray Severus Snape, according to Deadline. Known for his standout roles in I May Destroy You, Gangs of London, and Black Mirror, Essiedu brings a fresh energy to the table.

Unlike Rickman, who was in his 50s and 60s during the original films, Essiedu aligns with the book’s “canonical” age for Snape—31—offering a younger take on the potions master. Showrunner Francesca Gardiner has emphasized staying true to J.K. Rowling’s original timeline, and Essiedu’s casting fits this vision. But will his charm and talent win over fans who cherish Rickman’s iconic sneer?

Why Are Harry Potter Fans Divided Over This Casting?

The announcement has sparked a firestorm of reactions. Some fans applaud Essiedu’s acting chops, with one X user defending, “Has it occurred to Harry Potter fans that Paapa Essiedu simply was the best person for the job?” Others, however, are less convinced. Snape’s book description—sallow skin, greasy black hair, and a hooked nose—doesn’t quite match Essiedu’s conventionally handsome features, leading to cries of “blackwashing” and accusations of straying from canon. Beyond looks, the shift in Snape’s racial dynamic has raised eyebrows, with fans noting that scenes of James Potter bullying a now-Black Snape could carry unintended racial undertones in the 1970s Hogwarts setting.

How Does Paapa Essiedu Compare to Alan Rickman’s Legendary Snape?

Alan Rickman’s portrayal of Snape is nothing short of legendary, blending menace, heartbreak, and subtle humor into a performance etched in cinematic history. Essiedu faces the daunting task of following this legacy while carving out his own space. At 34, he’s closer to Snape’s book age, potentially offering a rawer, more volatile take on the character’s youth. Yet, fans on X lament, “There’s only one man who can be Professor Snape,” with many fearing Essiedu won’t replicate Rickman’s gravitas. Could Essiedu’s modern flair bring a new depth to Snape’s tortured soul, or will he struggle under Rickman’s long shadow?

Could Benedict Cumberbatch Have Been a Better Snape?

Amid the Essiedu buzz, some fans have floated Benedict Cumberbatch as an alternative. With his sharp features, brooding intensity, and proven range in roles like Sherlock and Doctor Strange, Cumberbatch seems tailor-made for Snape’s complexity. Though no reports link him to the HBO series, his name pops up in fan chatter as a “what if” casting dream. Compared to Essiedu, Cumberbatch’s older age (48) and closer resemblance to Rickman’s Snape might appease purists—but would he commit to a decade-long TV gig? For now, it’s pure speculation, but the idea keeps the fandom buzzing.

What Does This Casting Mean for the HBO Series’ Direction?

HBO’s Harry Potter series, slated for late 2026 or early 2027, promises a “faithful adaptation” of Rowling’s books, filmed at Warner Bros. Studios Leavesden. Essiedu’s casting, alongside John Lithgow as Dumbledore and rumors of Janet McTeer as McGonagall, suggests a blend of diversity and star power. Yet, the choice to diversify Snape’s character hints at a broader reinterpretation. Will this shift alter key dynamics—like Snape’s rivalry with James or his unrequited love for Lily? Fans worry it could reshape the story’s emotional core, while others see it as a bold evolution for a new generation.

Are Fans Overreacting to the Snape Casting News?

The internet has erupted with memes, rants, and mock suggestions like “Terry Crews as Harry Potter,” reflecting both humor and frustration. Posts on X reveal a split fandom: some decry Essiedu’s casting as “horrible,” while others urge patience, citing his Emmy-nominated talent. The backlash echoes past debates, like Noma Dumezweni’s casting as Hermione in The Cursed Child, which also faced racism and resistance. Is this a case of fans clinging too tightly to nostalgia, or are their concerns about story integrity valid? Time—and Essiedu’s performance—will tell.

Some Closing Thoughts:

As HBO’s Harry Potter series brews its magical revival, Paapa Essiedu’s casting as Severus Snape—and whispers of Benedict Cumberbatch—stand as a lightning rod for excitement and debate. Whether Essiedu will conjure the same spellbinding presence as Alan Rickman or redefine the role entirely remains a mystery. With production ramping up and the wizarding world watching, this bold choice signals a fresh chapter for Hogwarts—one that’s sure to keep fans talking until the premiere.

What do you think of Essiedu or Cumberbatch as Snape? Let the Sorting Hat of opinions decide!

We at The Omen Media strive to bring you your daily dosage of entertainment, one tantalizing story at a time. If you would like to support our efforts, and we would really appreciate it if you would, consider doing one of the the following:

1) Buy us a small cup of coffee by clicking here, or

2) You can also support us by becoming a Patreon member by clicking here. We don't have anything exclusive to offer to our Patreon members just yet as we are just a little movie website, but it still costs money to run one. For just $3 a month, you can support everyone who is working behind the scenes to get you your daily dose of entertainment one piece at a time.

Every support counts and every such gesture will serve as an additional motivation for us to keep bringing you your daily fix of showbiz.

Thank you for taking the time out to read this and we hope that you have a lovely day ahead!