Thunderbolts* Reviews: How Marvel’s Darkest Film Tackles Mental Health and Depression?

Marvel Studios’ Thunderbolts* is generating buzz as the first of Thunderbolts* reviews have poured in from early screenings, with critics and fans praising its bold exploration of mental health and depression.

Set to release on May 2, 2025, this Phase 5 finale introduces a team of antiheroes grappling with their pasts, offering a fresh, emotionally resonant take on the MCU.

Unlike typical superhero fare, the film dives deep into the psychological struggles of its characters, earning accolades for its gritty tone and standout performances, particularly from Florence Pugh and Lewis Pullman.

In this article, we explore how Thunderbolts* addresses these heavy themes based on initial reactions, shedding light on why it’s being called one of Marvel’s best films in years.

What Makes Thunderbolts* Stand Out in the MCU?

Early Thunderbolts* reviews highlight the film’s departure from the MCU’s usual formula. Critics describe it as “gritty, emotional, and unlike anything Marvel has done before,” with a tone reminiscent of Captain America: The Winter Soldier but infused with darker, more personal stakes.

The story centers on a team of misfits—Yelena Belova (Florence Pugh), Bucky Barnes (Sebastian Stan), Red Guardian (David Harbour), and others—brought together by Valentina Allegra de Fontaine (Julia Louis-Dreyfus) for a high-stakes mission.

What sets it apart is its focus on the “emotional wreckage of broken individuals.”

Reviewers note that the film doesn’t shy away from depicting the raw struggles of its characters, making it a compelling character-driven drama. This emphasis on flawed, relatable antiheroes resonates with audiences, especially those feeling jaded by traditional superhero narratives.

How Does Thunderbolts* Address Mental Health?

Thunderbolts* reviews consistently praise the film’s overt exploration of mental health. Critics like Sean Chandler emphasize that it’s “about depression, loneliness, and purpose,” portraying its characters as “reject characters” searching for meaning. Unlike previous MCU films that often undercut serious moments with humor, Thunderbolts* treats these themes with gravity.

Rendy Jones, a critic on X, notes, “Finally, a Marvel movie that treats mental health and depression as a serious matter and not like undercutting it for the sake of a quip.” The film’s narrative weaves these issues into the characters’ arcs, showing how their past traumas—experiments, brainwashing, and loss—shape their struggles. This approach makes the action sequences feel more impactful, as they’re grounded in emotional stakes.

Why Is Yelena Belova’s Depression Central to the Story?

Florence Pugh’s portrayal of Yelena Belova is a focal point in Thunderbolts* reviews, with critics calling her performance “superb” and “heart-wrenching.” Yelena, a Black Widow assassin, is depicted as battling a profound sense of emptiness, a theme introduced in a clip where she says, “There’s something wrong with me. An emptiness. I thought it started when my sister died, but now it feels like something bigger.”

Reviewers note that Yelena carries the film’s emotional weight, with her depression serving as a narrative anchor. Matt Neglia of Next Best Picture writes, “This may be a team-up film, but it very much belongs to Florence Pugh, who carries much of the dramatic weight of the movie on her back.” Her journey resonates with audiences, offering a relatable portrayal of grappling with loss and purpose.

How Do Other Characters Reflect Mental Health Struggles?

The ensemble cast also grapples with mental health challenges, adding depth to the team dynamic. Lewis Pullman’s Bob Reynolds/Sentry is frequently cited as a standout, with critics praising his “compelling” performance as a character wrestling with inner turmoil.

Sebastian Stan’s Bucky Barnes, a former Winter Soldier, evolves through his own struggles with guilt and redemption, with one reviewer highlighting a “scene-stealing moment” that underscores his growth.

Posts on X from fans and critics alike emphasize the team’s shared sense of being “flawed, broken, and regretful.” This collective vulnerability fosters camaraderie, making Thunderbolts* a story about finding connection amidst pain. As Mia Pflüger notes, the film “understands the void, the dark, and emptiness,” grounding its antiheroes in their shared trauma.

What Are Critics Saying About the Film’s Tone and Impact?

Thunderbolts* reviews describe its tone as “Marvel’s darkest material to date,” blending grounded action with horror-influenced elements. Sean Chandler mentions a “horror-influenced nightmare” in the final third, adding a unique psychological edge.

Critics appreciate how the film balances these darker themes with humor and heart, drawing comparisons to Guardians of the Galaxy for its focus on misfits finding family.

The film’s emotional resonance has left audiences moved, with Emily Murray of GamesRadar reporting shedding tears over its “genuinely emotional story.”

Brian Davids of The Hollywood Reporter adds, “I never expected a Marvel movie to tackle loneliness and depression in such a meaningful way.” This depth has led to claims that Thunderbolts* is “one of the best MCU movies in years.”

How Does the Film Set Up the Future of the MCU?

Beyond its mental health themes, Thunderbolts* is praised for feeling like a return to the MCU’s “Infinity Era,” with a focus on character and story over fan service. Critics note that it sets up Avengers: Doomsday, with the Thunderbolts team expected to play a central role.

The asterisk in the title, a nod to the disclaimer “The Avengers are not available,” hints at the team’s unique place in the MCU, leaning into self-aware humor.

Reviewers also tease surprising post-credits scenes, with Chris Gallardo calling the asterisk reveal a “shock” that will leave audiences buzzing. This blend of emotional depth and forward-looking storytelling positions Thunderbolts* as a pivotal chapter in the MCU’s evolution.

Why Should You Watch Thunderbolts*?

Thunderbolts* is shaping up to be a must-see for Marvel fans and anyone seeking a superhero film with substance. Thunderbolts* reviews underscore its bold approach to mental health and depression, offering a refreshing take on the genre.

With stellar performances, a dark yet heartfelt tone, and a story that resonates on a human level, it’s no wonder critics are calling it a “home run” for Marvel Studios.

Some Closing Thoughts:

As the film hits theaters on May 2, 2025, it promises to spark conversations about mental health while delivering the action and emotion fans crave.

Whether you’re drawn to Yelena’s poignant journey or the team’s gritty camaraderie, Thunderbolts* is poised to leave a lasting impact.

Grab your tickets and prepare for an MCU experience that’s as thought-provoking as it is thrilling.